Archives: Cases

  • Veve v Meketa [2023] PGNC 413; N10378

    PRACTICE & PROCEDURE – JUDICIAL REVIEW & APPEALS – Originating Summons – Order 16 Rule 5 NCR – Appointment Interim Managing Director – Section 138 NEA Act – Section 4 (1) (a) & (b) & 5 (a) (b) (c) Regulatory Statutory Authority (Appointment of Certain Officers) Act 2004 Appointment of CEO of Regulatory Statutory Office…

  • Twinza Oil (PNG) Ltd v Manau [2023] PGNC 189; N10236

    PRACTICE & PROCEDURE – JUDICIAL REVIEW & APPEALS – Substantive Notice of Motion – Whether Director Exceeded Authority Under Section 54 (2) Oil & Gas Act 1998– Whether in asking for Additional Information Required of Plaintiff by Instrument pursuant to Section 54 (2) Oil & Gas Act 1998 Acted Ultra Vires – Whether Instrument issued pursuant…

  • Bougainville Copper Ltd v Masono [2022] PGNC 506; N10031

    PRACTICE & PROCEDURE – JUDICIAL REVIEW & APPEALS – Notice of Motion – 7th Defendant By – Order 1 Rule 15 & Order 12 Rule 8 (4) & Order 12 Rule 1 NCR – Leave Extension of Time From Prior Orders – Filing Further Affidavits Annexing Victorian Supreme Court Decision – Whether Serious Prejudice Whether…

  • Himata v Warkia [2022] PGSC 32; SC2226

    JUDICIAL REVIEW – Application under Order 10 – Supreme Court Rules – Appealing against part of the decision of the leave Court – leave Court refused leave to apply for judicial review, and in addition, made further orders – considerations – whether Order 16 of the National Court Rules confers exclusive jurisdiction for interlocutory applications…

  • TST Development Ltd v Global Customs & Forwarding Ltd [2022] PGNC 183; N9613

    JUDICIAL REVIEW – Forfeiture of State Lease – Land Act 122 – Service of Notice to Show Cause on wrong address – effect thereof.

  • National Superannuation Fund Ltd v Yawenaik Holdings Ltd [2021] PGNC 447

    PRACTICE & PROCEDURE – Joinder Application – Whether sufficient interest to join –consolidation of proceeding – necessary for an effective determination of issues raised – material filed support joinder – balance discharged on probabilities – application granted – costs in the cause.

  • Inugu v Maru [2020] PGNC 404; N8649

    PRACTISE & PROCEEDURE – Judicial Review & appeals – Notice of motion – Leave to amend Order 16 Statement – Order 16 rule 13 (13) (1), Order 16 Rule 6 (2) & Order 8 rule 50 NCR – Amendment to determine real questions posed – avoiding multiplicity of proceedings – Material relied sufficient – no…

  • Ahwong v Ane [2020] PGNC 305; N8512

    PRACTISE & PROCEEDURE – Judicial Review & appeals – Originating summons – Third defendants Amended Notice of motion – Order 16 Rule 13 (13) (2) (a) & (b) (1) NCR – Dismissal of Proceedings – Abuse of court process – No reasonable cause of action – WS proceedings same matter on merit Dealt with –…

  • Gabutu v Russo [2020] PGNC 29; N8197

    PRACTISE & PROCEEDURE – Judicial Review & appeals – Substantive notice of Motion – State Lease – Certiorari Order 16 Rule 1 (1) NCR – Land Act 1996 – Ministerial declaration customary land –– Section 133 Land Act – No power revert back State Land – Abuse of process – no evidence compliance Sections 7,…

  • Bougainville Copper Ltd v Central Me’ekamui Exploration Ltd [2020] PGSC 8; SC1917

    SUPREME COURT- Application for Leave to Appeal, Supreme Court Act, s.14(3)(b) – Proposed appeal against order for the joinder of parties in the proceedings – National Court proceedings for judicial review under Order 16 – a discretionary judgement –relevant considerations in respect to the exercise of a discretionary power – discretionary power properly exercised. PRACTICE…